At school, Lincoln, Clyde, Rusty, and Zach are excited for Liam’s first ever sleepover at his farm. Suddenly, Girl Jordan arrives, and announces that she finally got a new swimming pool, and is inviting them to her party to celebrate. The boys are bummed, since they'd like to come, but decide to stay with Liam, since it's his first sleepover. Girl Jordan, however, says they can come as late as they want.
At Liam's farm, Liam is giving a tour of the farm for his friends. Once they're done, Liam says that they can start having fun now. Throughout the sleepover, the boys have fun wrangling chickens, riding on a goat, rolling down the hills in tires, and playing hide-and-seek. Throughout all these activities, the boys keep getting calls from their classmates showing all of the fun things they're missing out on at the pool party, such a make-your-own sandwich station, a tattoo station, and the pool, where Mollie plans on beating Lincoln's cannonball record. Not wanting to miss out on the things that look like fun, the boys suggest that they tire Liam out so they can sneak out. After drinking a glass of goat's milk, Liam finally falls asleep, leading the others to finally sneak out.
Arriving to Girl Jordan's pool party, the boys attempt get in on the enjoyment. Rusty heads to the make-your-own sandwich station, Zach heads to the tattoo station, and Lincoln and Clyde head to the pool. Unfortunately, the boys quickly run in various problems: Rusty accidentally puts hot sauce on his sandwich instead of ketchup, making his face swell up (since he's allergic to hot sauce), Zach's hair falls off when it is discovered that the hair dye he put on can be damaging to redheads, and Lincoln and Clyde have to swim in their underwear when there are no available swimsuits (and Girl Jordan's dog took their clothes). Realizing that the party is not as fun as they thought, the boys decide to head back to Liam's. However, when trying to sneak out, the boys are exposed in front of everyone, making everyone pull out their phones, and record their embarrassing moments. Upon leaving, Lincoln attempts to get his and Clyde's clothes back, but the dog ends up ripping them up.
The next day, the boys wake up, and Liam reveals that he knew that the boys snuck out last night because of their current conditions. Regardless, Liam is willing to forgive them because of their comeuppance (their humiliation being posted online) and decides to give them a bacon breakfast. As they eat, Liam reveals that he slaughtered his favorite pig, Virginia, to make the bacon, since she lost a mud wrestling match yesterday, making Clyde and Rusty pass out. Suddenly, Virginia is revealed to be perfectly fine, revealing it was just a joke, but Liam warns the viewers to never cross him, leaving Lincoln and Zach speechless at what they've just witnessed.